Can AI Make Our Videos, or Do We Still Need a Production Company?
In Short
- Sort the job by what viewers have to believe. Generate what viewers don't have to believe, and film what asks them to trust a person.
- Background visuals and renders of unbuilt spaces are fair game to generate. AI also helps with the admin around an edit.
- At a similar price, the cost shows up in the changes and the ownership. Ask about both before you choose.
- Ask any production company which tools they use at which step. Then work through a filmed, a mixed and a generated route for your brief together.
By AI video, we mean footage, people and voices made by a tool from a prompt or a photo, rather than filmed.
A video made entirely by such a tool may not belong to you. The Arts Law Centre of Australia says copyright needs a human author. Work made by AI without enough human input may not be protected at all.
That's one cost of generated video that arrives after the quick start. The others turn up in the changes you ask for and in whether viewers believe what they see.
Generating is the right call for some jobs. This guide sorts yours into what to generate and what to film, then shows how to compare the two before you decide.
Sort the Job by What Viewers Have to Believe
Generated video suits a job when viewers don't have to believe it. It suits a job badly when viewers need to trust what they see. A customer vouching for you, or a trainer, nurse or manager explaining how things are done, only works if viewers accept the person is real.
Two kinds of job are fair game for generating. Both can cost a production company the work. We'd still tell you the same.
- Need something to look at behind a social post? Generate it. If a post only needs a background, generated images or clips can do it. They will look like the generated posts other businesses make.
- Showing a building that isn't built? Use a render. A building that isn't built needs a render, not a film. We use generative tools for renders of unbuilt spaces.
Considering AI product pictures? Ask how you'll make changes. Clients have asked us to shoot a product once and place it in settings that don't exist. Some of them went back to filmed photography.
Generating something? Plan for the edit after it. A studio director on an industry panel described generated material going back through an editor, a team review, sound and an online pass. The time AI saves comes off the versioning work, and the creative roles stay.
Film Training Videos, Customer Stories and Anyone Speaking for Your Business
An NIQ article from 2024 reports that viewers picked out most AI-made ads as AI without being told, and felt less positive about the brands. The article isn't the study, and the tools have improved since, so read it as a pointer.
Training for staff? Film it. Buyers who have tried AI avatars for training have told us they walked away. The accents and the look felt weak, and the videos lost credibility with staff. Our view is that filmed, well-structured video is stronger.
Showing a customer? Use a real one. The ACCC says a review should be the genuine opinion of someone who used the product or service. Creating fake reviews is against the law. A generated customer has no experience to share.
Casting a child? Film a real one. A child watching wants to see a real kid push the button. A generated child can't react to the toy. We lost a toy campaign to generated children at the same price, so this is our view, and no certainty.
Putting a leader on screen? Film them. Your best manager, a clinic's lead nurse or a carer speaking to colleagues can't be generated and still be them. For more on standing out next to AI content, see standing out.
Price the Revisions and the Ownership, Not Just the First Clip
Some brands choose AI at the same cost as filming, to be early adopters. Generated work often ends up costing more than a real shoot. The cost shows up in the changes and in who owns the result.
Expecting to give notes? Ask how they'll be applied. In our experience, generated work is hard to refine with feedback. A filmed edit takes notes in rounds, which how do I give feedback on a video edit explains.
Building a campaign on a generated clip? Ask your lawyer who owns it. Editing human-made work with AI is more likely to count as human work than a clip generated from a prompt. Whether choosing and editing generated results is enough is unclear. The Arts Law page also says there's no legal duty to tell viewers AI was used, but suggests saying so to be transparent.
Footage you filmed is clearly human work, which is one more reason to film the people and generate the rest.
Wondering about time? See how long a video takes.
Ask Any Production Company How They Use AI
A good production company tells you which tools they use at which step, and what stays human. Here's what to ask, with what a good answer sounds like for each.
Which tools, for which step? A good answer separates two uses. We use AI for cataloguing, transcripts and timecodes, so a line from six episodes back is found in seconds. The cut itself isn't good enough yet, and we keep AI away from people on screen.
Who owns the rights, and are real people's likenesses involved? Ask before work starts. A good answer settles both before anything is made.
Can we work through this brief in three routes? Take a filmed route and a mixed one that films the people and generates the rest. Add a generated one for the parts that don't show people. A good answer shows the real time and cost of each side by side, which also gives you something to take to your boss.
Who directs the tools on my job? At a model vendor's industry event, the argument was that as generating gets easier, someone with taste has to direct the tools. In a room of video business owners, the argument was that a professional should drive the tools far better than a client. A good answer shows you how they'd do that on your job.
Our own video work is on our video production Melbourne page. We're Melbourne based and work Australia-wide.