What If the Agency and the End Client Give Different Notes on a Cut?
In Short
- Settle with both approvers, before the first cut, who breaks a tie.
- Agree script and voiceover disagreements before recording. The edit is built around them.
- Review the first cut with both approvers together, and ask for one answer.
- Is one approver confused? Keep the idea and change how it's shown.
An editor can follow one set of notes. If you hand over two that disagree, the edit stops until someone on your side chooses.
The agency and the end client each see something we can't, so we won't pick a side between them. The choice is also easier to make early. Here's how to settle it with both approvers, and what we do with the notes in the meantime.
Settle Who Breaks a Tie Before the First Cut
Choose one person on your side to break ties, and tell both approvers who it is. Put it in the review schedule, next to the dates. If you haven't done that yet, do it in the message that sends the notes.
That person also sends the editor the answer. Your production company then gets one direction, and a decision that doesn't change halfway through.
Settle Script and Voiceover Clashes Before Anyone Records
A script approved by two people loses one of them. One side may want the language to filter out the wrong buyers, while the other wants it simplified.
Get both sets of instructions in the same room before recording. Someone has to choose before the voiceover is cut. The edit is built around the voice.
Still arguing about a comedic script? Tell your production company. We shoot the whole script straight first, from every angle. Then we add the funnier pick-ups, so you can dial a scene up or down in the edit.
Review the First Cut With Both Approvers Together
Put both notes in one thread, on purpose. Add both approvers, with each note and its reason. Everything arrives together, and nobody argues a point separately.
Or review the cut live, with both approvers on the call. A good producer plays the cut, reads each change back and leaves the timeline open. We also export a reference version of each cut, so everyone can point back to the shot order and where the text sits.
Pick one channel for notes. Comments on a review link work well. Tell your production company if a tool doesn't suit how you work, so you can agree on another.
Ask your production company to wait for your answer. Agencies tell us a past supplier passed their notes straight to the end client. A good production company works your notes into the next cut, and your client only sees a version you've approved. How to build that review into the timeline is in working with agencies.
Turning the answer into notes the editor can act on is covered in giving feedback on a video edit.
One Approver Confused and the Other Isn't?
A confused approver has told you something useful. It doesn't mean the idea has to go.
When a reviewer finds an opening confusing, we keep the idea and change the shape. The approver who liked it keeps what they liked, and the confused one gets a version that makes sense to them. Ask the confused approver what they expected to see, and show both approvers what changed.
Expect a view from your production company. A good one says what it would do and why, then follows your answer. We'd rather say where we stand than leave you guessing.
You can see our past work, including jobs for agencies and their clients, on our video production page.