Do Our Business Videos Need Captions and to Be Accessible?

By Matt Smolen · Last reviewed

In Short

  • Plan three things: captions for people who can't hear, a transcript for people who'd rather read, and audio description for people who can't see.
  • Name the accessibility standard your organisation follows in the brief. W3C says most media is required by policy to meet WCAG Level AA.
  • Decide on audio description before the shoot. W3C says none is needed when the audio already has every important visual detail.
  • Ask for captions as burned-in versions and as separate files, and ask whether a transcript is in the quote.

The video is approved and delivered, and then someone in compliance, HR or your web team asks if it's accessible. If the answer is a scramble, the fixes land after the edit is locked.

Here's what the official Australian sources say about video, who each one is written for, and what we deliver. It explains what those sources say. It isn't legal advice, so check the current rules for your own videos.

What "Accessible" Means for a Video

Three things cover most of it. Each helps a different viewer, and each has its own requirement in the Web Content Accessibility Guidelines (WCAG), the international standard that W3C publishes.

WhatWho it's forWCAG 2.2 level
Captions (recorded video)People who can't hear the dialogue and other soundsLevel A
Captions (live)The same people, watching a live streamLevel AA
Audio descriptionPeople who can't see the videoLevel A (or a descriptive transcript instead), and Level AA
TranscriptPeople who'd rather read than watch or listenLevel AAA for video with sound (Level A for audio-only)
Text you can readPeople who find low-contrast text hard to readLevel AA

Level A is the minimum, Level AA adds more and Level AAA goes furthest. That's why audio description appears twice: Level A accepts a descriptive transcript instead, and Level AA asks for the description itself.

The Level AAA line is for a transcript of a video with sound. W3C says most media is required by governing policies to meet Level AA.

W3C says it doesn't recommend requiring Level AAA across a whole site as a general policy, since some content can't meet every AAA criterion.

Captions are more than subtitles. The Style Manual says subtitles show only the dialogue, while captions show any audio, including sound cues. W3C means a translation by "subtitles", as the FAQ says. W3C says captions should also say who is speaking and describe sounds the viewer needs.

A transcript is the text version. W3C also describes a descriptive transcript, which adds what's on screen. It says Deaf-blind people need one.

Audio description is narration. The Style Manual says it gives the visual details, such as the setting, a sign or a movement, during gaps in the dialogue.

Closed versus burned-in captions, and what a website player needs, are in video formats and sizes.

Which Rules Apply to Your Business

Four official sources are worth knowing. Three are written for government bodies, so the first job is to see which one is yours.

The Disability Discrimination Act. The Disability Discrimination Act 1992 is a federal Act. On the Federal Register of Legislation, section 24 is headed goods, services and facilities, and section 11 is headed unjustifiable hardship.

Whether the Act reaches your own videos is a question for a lawyer. For how it applies to digital content, you can also check the Australian Human Rights Commission's current guidance.

Victorian Government bodies. The Victorian Government's accessible communications policy says all new videos produced by Victorian Public Service bodies and Special bodies must include closed captions. It says to check auto-generated captions before publishing, and that a transcript is good practice. It also says to consider audio description and an Auslan version.

Its standards page says digital content must meet the current WCAG at Level AA at a minimum. That requirement "extends to all suppliers and vendors developing digital materials" for a Victorian public body.

The Digital Service Standard. Its services covered page says it's mandatory for services under the Investment Oversight Framework. It's also mandatory for new or replacement public-facing services, new staff-facing services and existing public-facing services. It names videos as an example of an informational service.

Its accessibility criterion tells agencies to comply with the Disability Discrimination Act, the latest WCAG and the Style Manual.

The Style Manual. It's the Australian Government's content guide. Its video page says audio-visual content must have a transcript, closed captions and an audio description. The exception is dialogue delivered straight to camera ("talking heads"), which needs no audio description.

The Victorian page says its standards bind Victorian Public Service bodies and Special bodies, and extend to their suppliers and vendors. The Style Manual and the Digital Service Standard are written for government bodies. For a Commonwealth or Victorian Government client, expect the brief to say which applies.

For another state or a council, ask what applies.

Which of Your Videos Need What

The three things don't land on every video the same way.

A person talking straight to camera. Captions apply, and the Style Manual's exception means no audio description for the speech. If the video also shows slides, charts or text the speaker doesn't read out, ask about it.

A film where the picture tells the story. A brand film or a walkthrough that shows things the voiceover doesn't say needs more thought.

W3C says no extra description is needed when the audio already has every important visual detail. If it doesn't, Level AA asks for audio description.

A film with no speech at all is a case to raise with your web person. WCAG asks for a text or audio alternative.

A live stream. Level AA asks for live captions. On our streams they come through the platform you're using, such as Zoom, Teams or YouTube, with its inbuilt tools.

W3C says automatic captions are only a starting point. It says [live captions are usually done by professional real-time captioners] (https://www.w3.org/WAI/media/av/captions/), also called CART providers (Communication Access Realtime Translation). If your organisation's standard needs more, raise it in the brief early.

How a live crew works is in How Do I Run a Professional Live-Streamed Webinar or Town Hall?.

Text on screen. The Style Manual asks for text in videos at a contrast of at least 4.5 to 1. We check caption and on-screen text contrast against your brand colours.

Motion and autoplay. The Style Manual says no autoplay and nothing flashing more than three times in a second. Ask your web person how your site's player behaves.

What We Deliver and What to Ask For

A good production company says what's in the quote and what isn't. Here's what's in ours, and the same questions work with any production company.

State the standard in the brief. Name the current WCAG at Level AA, or the level your organisation sets. Then everyone is working to the same target.

Ask for captions as a file and as a burned-in version. We deliver both as standard. The caption file is the closed version, which viewers can turn on and off, and the Style Manual prefers closed captions. The burned-in version suits screens without sound, such as conference screens.

You then don't need to come back to us for a version we haven't supplied.

Ask whether captions cost extra. Ours are factored into the edit process, and they don't add to the time or cost. If another production company quotes them as a line, ask what it covers.

Ask whether a person checks them. The Style Manual says to review and edit the accuracy and timing of captions for pre-recorded video. W3C says automatic captions are only a starting point for accurate ones.

Ask for a transcript if you need one. We supply them on request, either of the finished video or of the full interviews. The full interviews suit a paper edit, a recut or another use later.

Ask whether a transcript is in the quote or its own line.

If a transcript comes from automated software, the Style Manual says to review it for errors and correct them. Ask who does that, your production company or your own team. Its format puts non-speech sounds in square brackets and ends with the words "End of transcript".

Decide on audio description before the shoot. We work with a specialist for audio description. W3C says to plan accessibility from the very start of a project, to save time and money. It adds that integrated description needs to be in the script before filming.

Raise it on the first call, and ask whether it's included or a separate line.

Do captions only help people who are deaf?

No. W3C says captions are for people who are Deaf and others who can't hear the audio. People who process written information better than audio also use them. Subtitles in another language are a translation, and W3C says they're not directly an accessibility accommodation.

Can a transcript replace captions?

No. WCAG asks for captions on recorded video with sound, at Level A. Its one exception is a video that only repeats text already on the page, and the video must be clearly labelled as that.

What happens when a new WCAG version comes out?

W3C encourages using the latest version of WCAG, and the Digital Service Standard asks agencies to follow it. W3C says WCAG 2.2 came out on 5 October 2023, with an update on 12 December 2024. It describes WCAG 3 as an early draft. Name the version your organisation follows in the brief.

CallGet a SAME DAY quote