Will a Testimonial Video Bring Us Results, or Is It Just a Nice Video?

By Matt Smolen · Last reviewed

In Short

  • Treat a testimonial video as proof behind an offer people are already weighing. It should drive enquiries. The customer on screen is a lot like the customer you want more of.
  • Run it for at least a week before you change anything. If results are weak, the fix may be the headline, the offer or how you collect leads.
  • We judge it by return, not lead count. A $1,000 ad spend that returns $5,000 is a win, whether it brought one lead or forty.
  • Ask phone callers how they found you. Digital leads should be able to be tracked, but calls can't be unless you ask.

A customer testimonial video is a short film of one of your customers saying, in their own words, what changed after they chose you.

You'd like to know it will bring leads before you spend the money. A nice video that does nothing is easy to picture.

Here's what a testimonial does, where it should go and how to tell whether it worked.

A Testimonial Video Backs Up an Offer People Are Already Weighing

A testimonial video is proof that sits under an offer. Someone is already thinking about buying, often something expensive. They want to see a customer like them who chose you and was glad they did.

That's why it should drive enquiries. A real customer on camera is the closest match to the buyer you want more of. Who to pick is in How Do I Choose the Right Customer for a Testimonial Video?.

Even in an ad, the ask is the last small part of the video. The rest is the customer's story.

Results still depend on your offer, where the video runs and how you collect leads. A customer story on its own may not fix a weak offer.

Give the Video a Place to Go Before You Film It

Small businesses judge marketing on return, so settle where the video runs and what you expect from it.

Pick the place where a lead is deciding. That's usually the service page they read before they enquire, or an ad. How reviews and video work together is in We Already Get Plenty of Five-Star Google Reviews. Why Would We Need Video Testimonials as Well?.

No plan yet? Start with the service page. It's the page a customer reads before they enquire, so put the video there first. What the customer says on camera can also shape your website, offer and ads. You can see the stories we make at customer testimonial videos.

Regulated health service? Check Ahpra's rule before the video goes on your website or in an ad. Ahpra says the National Law doesn't allow testimonials to advertise regulated health services.

A Good Lead Count Depends on the Spend Behind It

No lead count suits every business. In our experience, spend changes it. The same video gets very different clicks and leads from organic posting, $10 a day on Meta, $100 a day or $1,000 a day.

Run it for at least a week before you adjust. After that week, we change one thing at a time. The fix may not be the video. It could be the headline, the offer on the page or how you collect leads.

Judge It by Return, Not by Lead Count

How we judge it is by what it costs to win a customer, compared with what that customer is worth to you over time.

Match the lead count to the customer's worth. Say a customer is worth $50 to $100 over their lifetime. In our experience you need a lot of leads to cover the ad spend.

Say they're worth $20,000 to $40,000. You need far fewer leads for the return to be clear.

A win is a win at any count. Put $1,000 into ads and win back $5,000 in closed business, and that's a great result from one lead. It's equally a success from forty.

It's case by case, so work out your own numbers before the ads run.

Ask Phone Callers How They Found You

Digital leads should be able to be tracked. Someone clicks an ad and leaves their details, and you can tie that to a lead and to closed business.

A phone enquiry is different. If you don't ask, you won't know it came from the video.

Add one question to the call. Ask "How did you hear about us?" and record the answer next to the enquiry.

Settle the measure before the shoot. Decide what you'll count, such as enquiries from the page that shows the video.

Should we leave testimonial videos until next quarter?

It's easy to put case studies off until sales asks for leads. Waiting means the stories you could already be using stay unmade. A typical project takes two to four weeks from brief to delivery, so asking early still leaves time.

Our ads have run for a week and nothing has come in. Is the video the problem?

Check the spend first. A few dollars a day gives few clicks, so few leads. If the spend is real, look at the headline, the offer or how leads are collected before you blame the video.

Can we post a testimonial video organically and still tell if it works?

Organic reach and leads are hard to quantify. Reach can be as vast as a paid ad spend. Clicks and leads vary widely, from $10 a day upward. So count the enquiries that follow, and ask each caller how they found you.

CallGet a SAME DAY quote