Do We Need a Creative Agency or a Production Company?

By Matt Smolen · Last reviewed

In Short

  • Work out which job you're buying: brand strategy, campaign ideas or making the video.
  • Hire an agency first if you need a broad read on your brand, new angles or a slogan, or want ad reporting.
  • Go to a production company if you already have the slogan and messages and need ideas for bringing them to life, plus the making.
  • Ask who will make the work, and what a company pitches back when the brief is broad.

Video production used to be expensive enough that a finished film had only two places to go: TV and cinema. That history explains why agencies and production companies have separate jobs, and why the line between them has blurred.

A creative agency manages the direction of a brand's marketing. A production company shoots, edits and delivers the video and photography.

Buyers with a campaign in mind often search for an agency first, since the word has prestige. It's a fair instinct, and it can cost you. You might pay for brand strategy your team has done, or skip ideas help you need.

This guide sorts the jobs and says when an agency is the better fit. It also shows what to ask a production company that offers the thinking too.

Why Agencies and Production Companies Split the Work

The gear was big, costly and unwieldy, so few brands touched video. Agencies managed the brand instead, with a big say in where its marketing went, and they ran print, PR and activations.

When a campaign needed a film, they partnered with a production company to make it from the creative brief.

That arrangement still runs, but it has blurred. Budgets are tighter, and marketing teams inside brands can often drive a lot of the strategy and the campaigns. Many production companies also do a lot of the creative thinking, so the title question is harder to answer than it used to be.

Work Out Which Job You're Buying

Start with where you are in the process and what help you need next. The jobs below often overlap, and one company can do several.

The jobUsually the best fit
A broad read on your brand: values, mission, purpose, reputation and competitorsAn agency
Slogans, new campaign angles, an outside viewAn agency
Ideas for bringing a campaign you've already set to life, then making itA production company
Print, PR and activationsOften run by an agency
Ad reporting, ROI or CPA trackingAn agency may suit better
Making the video and photography from a brief or an ideaA production company

When an Agency Is the Better Fit

Each point below could mean a job goes to an agency, not to us. A good production company says so and points you to the better fit.

Need a read on your whole brand? Start with an agency. An agency takes a broad, holistic view of the brand: its values, mission and purpose, how people see it and how competitors position themselves. The result shows how your business is placed in its market.

An agency does this best, so start there if your team hasn't done the work. It's less useful if your internal team already does it.

Want new angles or a slogan? Ask an agency. It reworks the angles and the messaging to get the most out of the brand, then presents a direction for you to approve.

Already have an agency you like? Keep it. Your production company takes the brief from the agency. How Does a Production Company Work With Our Agency? covers how the two divide the work.

Need ad reporting, ROI or CPA tracking? An agency may suit you better. Tracking what ads return is a different job from making them. How Can I Use an External Content Partner Instead of an In-House Team or an Agency? covers the ongoing partner arrangement.

If You Already Have the Slogan, Start With a Production Company

Say you have your slogan and key messages, and you want a campaign made. What you need is ideas for bringing them to life, and then the video or photography. A production company is a direct line to both.

We've worked on numerous campaigns that started with a brief like this one. Brands are usually strong on what they want to say. What they need help with is how to get there, and that's the part we pitch on.

Some call this a creative agency production company. We describe ourselves as end-to-end, from ideation to delivery.

We come back with top-level concepts, a ballpark cost for each and the pros and cons. We drive the ideas and work through them with you. Our brand videos page shows what we've made for brands, and we work Australia-wide from Melbourne.

Why one company can cost less. Most traditional agencies don't have video production in house, so they bring in a production company. Split the work and you pay different parties for the one project. One company that thinks and delivers means paying once, and no idea passed between two parties.

Check Who's Pitching and Who's Making

The same checks work on an agency and on any production company.

Ask who will make the work. On a split job, one party sells you the idea, then another sells you on the people who'll make it. With one company, you're talking to the people who will actually make it. How Do I Choose a Video Production Company? covers how to check who does what.

Ask what a company would pitch back on a broad brief. We come back with top-level concepts, a ballpark cost for each, and pros and cons. Any company should be able to tell you what it does at that stage, and who does it.

Don't rule out a production company for not calling itself an agency. One that never uses the word can still plan and pitch campaign ideas, and it's easy to miss. Ask what it does at campaign level, and who does it.

Our marketing team already sets the strategy. What do we hand a production company?

The slogan, the key messages and where the campaign will run, such as digital, TV and radio. Then ask how it could come to life. If your team can do the brand read, an agency adds less.

If we use both, which comes first?

The agency, when you need the brand read, a slogan or new angles, since it sets the direction. The production company takes the creative brief from there. On that split, the production company quotes the agency, and the agency adds that as a line in its own quote to you.

Is a "creative agency production company" a real thing?

Some production companies cover the ideas as well as the making, so the term exists. It isn't a standard, so judge a company by what it does at each stage, using the checks above.

CallGet a SAME DAY quote