Should We Use Real Staff and Customers or Actors in Our Video?

By Matt Smolen · Last reviewed

In Short

  • Use real staff or customers when who they are is part of the message, and always for a testimonial.
  • Use paid talent for a scripted scene, a presenter with a lot to say or a big volume of content.
  • Cast actors to look believable, but don't present them as real customers. Say in the brief which is which.
  • Real people need topics and time on their terms. Actors need a signed-off script and a casting window.

Most people treat this as a cost question. Staff don't charge a fee, and actors do. Staff time isn't free either: non-actors often work more slowly, and the time that costs can add up to as much as hiring an actor.

That instinct can put the wrong people on screen. The better question is what the video says about who's in it.

A customer's story needs a real customer. A scripted ad that repeats one scene all day often needs a professional.

By real people, we mean your own staff and customers. Talent means paid actors and presenters, usually booked through an agent. Here's how to decide between them, and what the choice changes in your brief and on the day.

Use Real People When Who They Are Is Part of the Message

Use your own staff or customers when the video is showing who's involved, or what the experience is like. The viewer should be able to say, "That's someone like me."

A testimonial always uses a real customer. If the response isn't genuine, viewers don't see their own problem in it. They don't act on it either.

Training staff can represent the team. We've made training videos for retail and QSR businesses with the team in front of the camera. They don't read from an autocue for a living. They're strong workers, and the people watching recognise them as the workforce, and may see or hear from them elsewhere in the business.

A leader in a parody is a casting choice that belongs to the idea. Leaders rarely act at work, and that contrast can be the point.

Use Paid Talent When the Job Is Pacing, Repeats or Volume

Hire talent when the video needs delivery more than it needs identity. Three jobs usually call for it.

A scripted scene with characters. A TV commercial with actors playing out a scenario needs pacing, emotion and consistency.

A presenter with a lot to say. Long stretches of dialogue off a teleprompter need someone who can deliver them clearly and confidently, and quickly.

A lot of content to get through. The retail and QSR training above could go the other way. With a long list of modules to film, a professional who has done it many times moves faster.

We've seen the same project made both ways. The choice comes down to the point of the video and how fast you need to film. The impression you want to leave and the budget count too.

Sometimes it doesn't need to be stated that someone is paid talent. They're there to get the message across better. That applies to scripted scenes and presenters, not for testimonials.

Mix Them, but Don't Pass One Off as the Other

A mix works when each person plays what they are. A professional can lead a scene, with your own people around them as themselves. Cast actors to look believable, but don't claim they're real customers.

Cast the lead for the performance. The lead delivers the lines and the emotion, so that's where a professional earns the fee.

Choose the extras as carefully as the lead. In an ad, much of the brand's look comes from the extras. Curate them as you would the lead.

Don't half-commit. A client of ours criticised an ad that opened with a "based on real events" card and then showed glamorous actors in unrealistic settings. Their view was to either use actors and not claim otherwise, or use real people.

We agree. You can't get away with fakery any more.

Tell Your Production Company Who's on Camera and Why

Write one line in the brief for each person on camera, saying who viewers should take them to be. For example: "Two actors playing a couple, not presented as customers."

Real people? Give them topics and key messages. Don't give them a script or the questions. how to calm on-camera nerves covers why, and how to make people comfortable.

Actors? Allow for casting and a signed-off script. Casting is part of pre-production, which needs at least two weeks. Name who signs the script off, and do it before the shoot, since actors read it as written.

Decide where the video will run before casting, and put it in the brief. Where it runs and for how long sets what an actor's contract allows. what happens in pre-production has the detail.

Staff and customers sign a release form even when they're unpaid. Who signs what has its own guide.

Real people bring a risk that actors don't. A real customer can't simply be recast. real people in ads and shelf life covers what to plan for.

Plan the Day Around Who's on Camera

The choice changes how a shoot day runs.

Real people? Let them set the pace. Book a set block of time, let them choose when, and have the crew set up before they arrive. For unpaid people, we usually bring a small thank-you.

Actors? The day runs to the script. Professionals can repeat a scene the same way, take after take.

Allow time for prompter pieces. On our jobs, a piece to camera off a prompter has run roughly fifteen minutes once set-up, stumbles and resets are counted. Use that as a rough planning figure, and ask your production company for theirs. A good production company films the prompter pieces first and checks what's missing afterwards.

You can see the people we film on our corporate video page.

What if a role is still open days before the shoot?

A good production company tells you early and brings fixes. That means options, a date to decide by and a fallback. Changing talent late usually costs, depending on availability and usage. On one job, we offered to absorb a small gap in an actor's rate rather than lose a good actor.

How do we choose between two actors for a role?

Cast the pairing and how believable the purchase is, not just an age band. If it's a vehicle ad, the customer should look like someone who could buy it and get along with the dealer. Ask your production company to show reels for each actor, with the age range each can play.

Can an actor play a customer in our ad?

In a scripted scene, yes. It doesn't always need to be stated that someone is paid talent. A testimonial is different, and has to be a real customer giving a genuine response. Don't script an actor to say they're a customer. Check your own ad with a lawyer or agency.

CallGet a SAME DAY quote