Should Our Corporate Video Be Animation or Live Action?

By Matt Smolen · Last reviewed

In Short

  • Choose animation for what a camera can't show, such as data, dashboards and ideas that are hard to picture. Choose live action when viewers need to see real people and places.
  • Try a hybrid first. A real presenter or interview builds trust, and animation shows the dashboards, trends and connections.
  • Settle the script, storyboard, pacing and look before animation starts. The hard work happens at the build, so there's no fixing it on the day.
  • Use animation on purpose, in your brand's look. Animation added for its own sake doesn't help the video.

Your brief has two lines that pull in different directions. One says to show how the new reporting platform pulls data from five systems. The other says to put your own people on screen, so staff trust it.

One person says animation. Another says film it. Both sound right.

They are, for different parts of the video. By animation we mean pictures, charts, text and characters that move on screen, from motion graphics to 2D and character work.

Live action means filming real people and places. This guide helps you decide which one each part needs, and what to settle before the animation starts.

Choose Animation for What a Camera Can't Show

Animation suits information that's complex, where a visually simple picture does the explaining. These four tests tell you when.

Is it data or a process? Charts, statistics and step-by-step processes read faster as moving graphics than as someone describing them. For example, a retail and QSR group's sales by store, or an industrial maker's path from order to dispatch.

Does it live behind a screen? Software interfaces, digital processes and abstract ideas have nothing for a camera to point at. Animation shows them working, with no location shoot or props.

Is the idea hard to picture? Explainer videos for a product or a service often suit animation, and animation can draw an idea your audience has never seen. Imagery that connects one idea to the next also keeps a complex video moving.

Would filming it cost too much? A place that transforms, or a scenario that takes sets, locations and a cast, can be too costly to film. Character animation can tell these scenarios too.

Choose Live Action When Viewers Need to See a Real Person or Place

Live action is authentic. Viewers see real places and real people, and that gives them a human connection to what's on screen.

That suits a customer's story, a manager welcoming new staff or a nurse describing the care on their ward. Viewers recognise their own situation in it. Whether those people should be your staff and customers or actors is a separate decision.

A live shoot also leaves room to find the best moment on the day. Animation has no such moment. It's planned and built in advance, which matters in the last section.

Generated video is a third route. It suits some jobs and fits badly where viewers must trust a person. For when it works and when it doesn't, see Can AI Make Our Videos, or Do We Still Need a Production Company?.

Try a Hybrid: A Real Person for Trust, Animation for the Data

A hybrid is usually our recommendation. It stops you giving up either the human connection or the clarity.

Ground the video with a real person, either presenting to camera or interviewed in their own office. Then let animation bring to life what's hard to demonstrate. That means dashboards, a trending graph, data sources and endpoints, and how different pieces of information connect.

For example, a head of operations explains the year's results to camera. Animation traces the trend line and shows where the numbers come from. Each part does the job it does best.

Training videos use the same split, with a presenter for the talking and animated graphics for complex ideas. How Do I Make Training Videos People Actually Watch? covers that.

Settle the Plan Before Animation Starts

Animation runs the opposite way to a shoot. On a shoot day, the crew can see and capture what works. Animation does its hard work at the build, so a large change after that means redoing it.

That puts the thinking up front. Settle these before the build starts:

  • the script
  • the storyboard, which is the scenes drawn in order
  • the pacing, meaning how long each idea stays on screen, which you can judge by whether the voiceover reads comfortably against the storyboard
  • the style, look and feel

Settle the look and the timeline at the start. Ask to approve the look before full production, and for a timeline set when the job begins. Animation can take longer than the 2 to 4 weeks of a typical project.

Ask too who makes any character or 3D parts. Our crew make 2D animation and motion graphics, and a partner makes the rest. The brief, the delivery and your point of contact stay with us.

Check it's on purpose and on brand. Colours, type and movement should follow your brand guidelines, so the animation looks like it came from you.

Ask what the animation does that a camera couldn't. If the answer is nothing, film it. That advice may cost us a job.

Does a Live-Action Production Company Also Make Animation, or Does It Subcontract? covers what to ask any company. To see what we've made, visit animation and motion graphics.

Is animation cheaper than live action?

Not always. Style, length, 2D or 3D and characters can change the scope quickly, so there's no standard price. It can cost less where filming would need sets, locations and a cast. To quote it, we need the goal, the style, where it will run, who will watch and a budget range. We often give a short concept summary with a ballpark first, then a specific quote once the project is clear.

Can we update an animated video later without reshooting?

Yes. Animated graphics can be updated without picking up a camera, so a changed figure or product name needn't mean a reshoot. A filmed person can't be changed that way. It's worth knowing which parts are likely to change before you choose.

Can we film a presenter on greenscreen instead of hiring a location?

Yes. Chroma key and compositing puts a presenter filmed on greenscreen against animated or designed backgrounds. It removes the need for an expensive location hire and keeps the presenter front and centre.

CallGet a SAME DAY quote